Previous Entry Share Next Entry
Oh, JE, why do you do this? (WC meta)
Matt TNH 1
doctor_fangeek
So I had an interesting conversation with another WC fan a few weeks ago, in which we agreed that we would buy the idea that *Neal thinks* he was "born bad," but (IIRC) disagreed as to Jeff Eastin's take on it. 

They said they didn't think he really believes that this is something that is true of the character, and that when he says that he's probably talking about the character's perspective.  I maintained that he seems to be pretty clear on the fact that he actually conceives of being "born bad" as something that *is* true of the character. 

Which, btw, I find to be an extremely frustrating view of things.  This is both because I don't think it fits with the way people, for the most part, work, and because I think it oversimplifies a complex character.  I would posit that, except for perhaps some rare extreme cases, people aren't simply born bad.  We are a product of *both* our genetics and our environment, and we are capable of change.  I have also said, in previous posts, that while I understand the need for continued tension in terms of the storytelling (e.g. Will Neal ultimately choose to be the con or the man?), I don't think one needs to invoke some sort of predestination to have that tension.  Change is *hard*.  Habits are hard to break.  It can be hard to learn to let people in if you have had to fend for yourself (or if you've been "burned" in the past, etc.).  No "born bad" is required.

Anyway, I just came across the following Twitter exchange, in which JE is pretty clear:

Fan: To you, was Neal born bad, or does he believe that he was born bad?
Jeff Eastin: Both.

So, yeah.  Argh.

  • 1
Six words for you:

Jeff Eastin is STILL a poopyhead.

:-)

That was almost the subject header of my post.

Then again, I guess on the bright side there's the fact that the character we get on screen is more complex than JE's misguided mindset. I wonder what Matt thinks of the whole thing? Inquiring minds want to know.

Also, new icon. ::grin::

Love it!

I saw that tweet and wanted to slap the crap out of him.

Thanks for your share! very impressive!


I'm working on the idea that Neal's obsessed with his bad blood because his dad was indeed uber-bad. Know how Jeff takes his molds from pop history/culture? Back in the 80's there was the CIA guy who actually was the first CIA man to defect to Russia, Edward Lee Howard. He had one son, left behind in America with his wife Mary when he defected to Russia. Of course following Jeff's pattern, the name and details would be changed. Hee. For some reason when Elrhiarhodan did her story in which Neal's dad is an FBI baddie, that clicked with Eddie in my head. Have a book by Howard and one contra Howard, just to browse. I was busy raising children and making money during that time and remember nothing of it. Ideas?

Edited at 2012-01-17 03:45 pm (UTC)

  • 1
?

Log in

No account? Create an account